Tue Nov 29, 2016 2:40 am by bob
If the toggles buttons are showing on one of the screens but not the others, then it is more likely they just happen to be configured to display off screen. The things I wrote in IRC should have hooked up your prior configuration.
The How would you like to control the game, is not really trial and error. The defaults should be more than suitable from my look at your older profile. The only real difference is if you want the click button overlay for action bars, then you might want to just assign it to your new character set, which you can do by selecting your character set in the top left, then select Menus in the lower left, and then in the lower right, highlight the appropriate menu (for an ISB42 config, this will be ISB42 - Standard).
You shouldn't mix and match key maps created via ISb41 and menus created via ISB42 and vs, because they will reference the wrong things.
It might be worth using the File -> Save As option. Save a backup, then File -> Clear, and setup the profile from scratch. Then you wont be mixing and matching things.